Books at school

Was your child assigned a book you're not comfortable with?

You're not being difficult. You're being a parent. Here's a calm, respectful way to ask for a different book, with a letter you can send, a phone script, your rights, and your options if things don't go well.

1

Know what's in it

Look the book up in our library and read its content guide, so you can speak to the teacher with confidence.

2

Pick an alternate

Choose a book with a similar theme or reading level. We suggest swaps for many common school books.

3

Reach out kindly

Start with a friendly note or call. Most teachers say yes when you offer a plan that still meets their goals.

4

Put it in writing

If the answer is no, send the formal letter, ask for the district's policy, and request a meeting with the principal.

5

Know your options

If the school won't work with you, you can choose another school or bring your child home to learn.

Often assigned in school

These books show up on a lot of school reading lists and in class read-alouds. Tap one to see its content guide and suggested alternates.

Write your letter

Fill in what you know. The letter and phone script update as you type. Nothing you enter is saved or sent anywhere.

Phone call script

Some things go better with a quick call. Keep it short and warm, then follow up in writing.

If things get hard

"If it is possible, as far as it depends on you, live at peace with everyone." Romans 12:18 (NIV). Stay kind, and stay firm.

Keep notes

Write down every call and meeting: the date, who you spoke with, and what was said. Save every email.

Go up one step at a time

Teacher first, then the principal, then the district office or superintendent, then the school board. Ask each one in writing.

Ask for the policy

Ask for the district's written policy on alternate assignments and on objecting to instructional materials. Many districts have one.

Ask about your child's grade

Ask in writing that your child won't lose points for reading the alternate book and completing comparable work.

Bring a friend

You can bring your spouse, a pastor, or another parent to a meeting for support.

Pray before every step

Ask God for wisdom and favor (James 1:5). The goal is your child's heart, not winning an argument.

Your rights as a parent

We're not lawyers, and this isn't legal advice. It's a starting point so you know where you stand. Laws change, so check your state's current law or talk with an attorney if things become serious.

The U.S. Supreme Court

In Mahmoud v. Taylor (June 2025), the Court ruled 6–3 that parents have a First Amendment right to have their children excused from lessons that burden their religious beliefs. The case involved storybooks read in elementary classrooms. It builds on earlier cases like Pierce v. Society of Sisters and Wisconsin v. Yoder, which recognize parents' right to direct their children's upbringing and education.

Georgia

Georgia's Parents' Bill of Rights (O.C.G.A. § 20-2-786) gives parents "the right to direct the upbringing and the moral or religious training" of their child and "the right to review all instructional materials intended for use in the classroom." Schools must have a procedure for parents to object to instructional materials.

Florida

Florida's Parents' Bill of Rights (Fla. Stat. § 1014.04) includes the same right to direct a child's moral and religious training. Section 1014.05 requires each district to have a process for parents to object to materials based on beliefs about morality, sex, and religion.

Other states

Louisiana and Oklahoma also have Parents' Bill of Rights laws, and many other states have passed parental rights laws in recent years. Search your state's name plus "parents' bill of rights," or ask your district for its policy on instructional materials.

Sources: Free Speech Center: Mahmoud v. Taylor · O.C.G.A. § 20-2-786 · Florida Statutes ch. 1014 · NCSL: Parents' Bill of Rights (2023)

The homeschool route

If your school won't work with you, homeschooling is legal in every state, and thousands of families make the switch every year. Do it the right way so your child is never counted as truant.

  1. Learn your state's law. Requirements are different in every state. HSLDA has a state-by-state guide.
  2. Withdraw in writing. Send the school a short, dated withdrawal letter and keep a copy.
  3. File any notice your state requires. In Georgia, you file a Declaration of Intent online with the Georgia Department of Education within 30 days of starting, then by September 1 each year after.
  4. Keep simple records. Attendance, the books you read, and samples of your child's work.
  5. You don't have to do it alone. Online programs, tutors, and co-ops can carry as much or as little as you need.

Source for Georgia steps: Homeschool Fox: Withdrawing from public school in Georgia and the Georgia Department of Education.

Need support?

Remote Learning Academy

Family Bookshelf is a ministry of Remote Learning Academy, an online homeschool, tutoring, and electives program built on faith and academic excellence. If you're thinking about homeschooling, we'd love to walk with your family.

Visit Remote Learning Academy

Often assigned in school

Yellow · DiscernmentCharlotte's WebGreen · Read freelyMr. Popper's PenguinsGreen · Read freelyLittle House on the Prairie (series)Green · Read freelyIsland of the Blue DolphinsYellow · DiscernmentWhere the Red Fern GrowsYellow · DiscernmentOld YellerYellow · DiscernmentHatchetYellow · DiscernmentWonderYellow · DiscernmentThe Lion, the Witch and the WardrobeRed · Not recommendedThe HobbitRed · Not recommendedHarry Potter and the Sorcerer's StoneGreen · Read freelyThe Bronze BowGreen · Read freelyThe Hiding PlaceYellow · DiscernmentLittle WomenRed · Not recommendedMagic Tree House (series)Red · Not recommendedMatildaYellow · DiscernmentHolesGreen · Read freelyThe Wild RobotYellow · DiscernmentThe GiverYellow · DiscernmentBridge to TerabithiaRed · Not recommendedA Wrinkle in TimeRed · Not recommendedPercy Jackson and the OlympiansYellow · DiscernmentThe Hunger GamesGreen · Read freelyMisty of ChincoteagueRed · Not recommendedThe Secret GardenGreen · Read freelyStuart LittleRed · Not recommendedThe Indian in the CupboardYellow · DiscernmentShilohGreen · Read freelyFrindleGreen · Read freelyBlack BeautyGreen · Read freelyMy Side of the MountainYellow · DiscernmentThe Diary of a Young GirlGreen · Read freelyThe CrossoverGreen · Read freelyNew KidGreen · Read freelyA Long Walk to WaterGreen · Read freelyThe Westing GameYellow · DiscernmentTuck EverlastingYellow · DiscernmentGhostGreen · Read freelyJohnny TremainGreen · Read freelyThe Wednesday WarsYellow · DiscernmentTangerineGreen · Read freelyHattie Big SkyYellow · DiscernmentBecause of Winn-DixieYellow · DiscernmentThe Tale of DespereauxGreen · Read freelySarah, Plain and TallGreen · Read freelyNumber the StarsYellow · DiscernmentThe OutsidersYellow · DiscernmentThe Watsons Go to Birmingham—1963Yellow · DiscernmentBud, Not BuddyYellow · DiscernmentRoll of Thunder, Hear My CryYellow · DiscernmentThe PearlYellow · DiscernmentThe Call of the WildYellow · DiscernmentTo Kill a MockingbirdYellow · DiscernmentOf Mice and MenYellow · DiscernmentThe Great GatsbyYellow · DiscernmentFahrenheit 451Yellow · DiscernmentAnimal FarmYellow · DiscernmentNineteen Eighty-FourYellow · DiscernmentLord of the FliesYellow · DiscernmentThe Scarlet LetterYellow · DiscernmentAdventures of Huckleberry FinnYellow · DiscernmentTheir Eyes Were Watching GodYellow · DiscernmentThings Fall ApartYellow · DiscernmentNightYellow · DiscernmentThe CrucibleYellow · DiscernmentA Raisin in the SunYellow · DiscernmentThe OdysseyYellow · DiscernmentBeowulfYellow · DiscernmentRomeo and JulietYellow · DiscernmentMacbethYellow · DiscernmentHamletYellow · DiscernmentJulius CaesarYellow · DiscernmentOthelloYellow · DiscernmentKing LearRed · Not recommendedA Midsummer Night's DreamYellow · DiscernmentTwelfth NightYellow · DiscernmentMuch Ado About NothingRed · Not recommendedThe TempestGreen · Read freelyShakespeare's Sonnets 18, 73, and 116Yellow · DiscernmentThe Tell-Tale HeartYellow · DiscernmentThe Cask of AmontilladoYellow · DiscernmentThe Fall of the House of UsherYellow · DiscernmentThe Masque of the Red DeathYellow · DiscernmentThe Pit and the PendulumYellow · DiscernmentThe Black CatYellow · DiscernmentThe RavenGreen · Read freelyAnnabel LeeGreen · Read freelyThe BellsGreen · Read freelyA Dream Within a DreamGreen · Read freelyRobert Frost: School PoemsGreen · Read freelyEmily Dickinson: School PoemsGreen · Read freelyLangston Hughes: Poems and "Thank You, Ma'am"Yellow · DiscernmentWalt Whitman: School PoemsYellow · DiscernmentMaya Angelou: School PoemsGreen · Read freelyI Wandered Lonely as a CloudGreen · Read freelyOzymandiasGreen · Read freelyThe Ransom of Red ChiefYellow · DiscernmentThe LotteryYellow · DiscernmentThe Most Dangerous GameYellow · DiscernmentThe Legend of Sleepy HollowYellow · DiscernmentRip Van WinkleGreen · Read freelyThe Minister's Black VeilYellow · DiscernmentYoung Goodman BrownRed · Not recommendedLooking for Alaska

Write your letter

Fill in what you know. The letter and phone script update as you type. Nothing you enter is saved or sent anywhere.

Dear [Teacher's name],

Thank you for all you do for [Child's name] and the class. I saw that the class will be reading [Assigned book].

After looking into the book, our family has decided, based on our personal beliefs and convictions, that [Child's name] won't be reading it. I'd like to ask whether [Child's name] could read [Alternate book] instead and complete similar assignments, so [Child's name] still learns the same skills and concepts you're teaching in this unit.

I'm happy to help find a book that fits your goals, and I want to make sure this doesn't create extra work for you. Please let me know what works best.

Thank you so much for understanding.

[Your name]
[Your phone or email]

Phone call script

"Hi, this is [Your name], [Child's name]'s parent. Do you have a few minutes? Thank you.

I saw that the class is reading [Assigned book]. I really appreciate you, and I'm not trying to make things hard. Based on our family's beliefs and convictions, [Child's name] won't be reading this one.

Could [Child's name] read [Alternate book] instead and do similar assignments? I want [Child's name] to still learn everything you're teaching in this unit. What goals or skills are you focusing on, so I can make sure the alternate book fits?"

If they say yes: "Thank you so much. I'll send a quick email so we both have it in writing."

If they're unsure: "I understand. Who should I talk to next, and is there a district policy on alternate assignments? I'll follow up in writing too."

If they say no: "Thank you for hearing me out. I'm going to put my request in writing and ask to meet with the principal. I really do want to work this out together."

The Family Bookshelf is free to use. It's funded by donations and affiliate links, which never cost you more and never change our ratings. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Get Involved