← Library
Shiloh by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor — book cover
Yellow · Discernment

Shiloh

by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor

A thoughtful Newbery winner about right and wrong. Yellow for animal abuse, lying, and some rough language from the owner.

A boy hides an abused beagle from its cruel owner and wrestles with lying to protect him.

Format
Chapter book
Ages
Middle Grade 9–12
Reading level
Lantern · Estimated
Faith
Clean secular
Tags
Language

Get this book

Find it on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. It never costs you more, and it never changes our ratings.

Try this instead

Content guide

Positive elements

Compassion and wrestling with honesty.

Spiritual content

Marty prays and thinks about what God wants.

Romance & sexual content

None.

Violence & scary content

The dog is abused and later badly hurt. The owner shoots a deer out of season.

Language

Some rough language from the dog's owner. Count needs verification.

Crude humor & disrespect

None.

Other things to know

A great conversation starter about lying.

Talk about it

  • Was Marty right to lie? What else could he have done?

Teach with this book

Charlotte Mason-style ideas for homeschool parents and teachers. What is narration?

Teach with this book

Charlotte Mason-style ideas for homeschool parents and teachers. These questions fit any book of this kind. What is narration?

Narration

Read one chapter (or let your child read it once), then ask for an oral narration: "Tell it back to me, as if I hadn't heard it." Ages 10 and up can sometimes write their narration instead.

Questions to think about
  1. Narrate the chapter: what happened, in order?
  2. Which character's choices did you admire? Which didn't you?
  3. Was there a moment when a character had to choose between right and easy?
  4. How has the main character changed so far?
  5. What does this story say about what is true, good, or beautiful?
  6. If you could ask the author one question, what would it be?
Character and integrity
  1. Who in this book showed integrity, doing what was right even when no one was watching or when it cost them something?
  2. Was a character tempted to lie, cheat, or take the easy way? What did they choose, and what were the consequences?
  3. Which character are you most like? Which one would you like to be more like, and why?
  4. Think of a time you faced a choice like the main character's. What did you do? What would you do now?
Point it to the Bible
  1. Is there a person or story in the Bible that reminds you of this book? How are they alike?
  2. Where did you see something true or good that points back to God, even though the book doesn't mention Him?
  3. Did anything in this book disagree with what the Bible teaches? How would you answer it from Scripture?
Assignment ideas
  • Oral narration after each chapter; ages 10 and up can write one narration a week.
  • Copywork: copy a beautiful or important sentence each week.
  • Dictation (ages 9 and up): study a short passage, then write it as it's read aloud.
  • Commonplace book: keep a notebook of lines worth remembering.
  • Character letter: write a letter to or from one of the characters.
  • Narrate from another view: tell one scene from a different character's point of view.

Parent reviews

Share a parent review

Loading…

Did we miss something?

The Family Bookshelf is free to use. It's funded by donations and affiliate links, which never cost you more and never change our ratings. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Get Involved